Neighborhood Center

Bay Shore Commons

Bay Shore Commons is a 109,295 SF Neighborhood Center at 521-605 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore, NY, USA, with 14 tenants including Stop & Shop, Chase, and Retro Fitness. In the last 24 months it recorded 0 openings and 2 closings. The 10-minute drive-time population is 70,279 with a median household income of $123,253, according to Brandmarch.

Open-air·14 stores across 109,295 SF·521-605 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore, NY, USA·Website

Recent Activity in Last 24 months

Dates shown here are when each event was detected. Actual event may have occurred up to 30 days earlier. Next digest sends Sunday.

Closed
AT&T583 E. Main Street · Plaza
Closed ~Nov 2025
Closed
Huntington Learning Center607 East Main Street
Closed Q1 2025
Showing 1-2 of 2 activities
Locations · Growth Trajectory

-2 net stores since Q4 2024

Shrinking tenants · 0 opens, 2 closes

About Bay Shore Commons

Bay Shore Commons is a 109,295 square foot grocery-anchored neighborhood shopping center located on Montauk Highway in Bay Shore, New York. The center features 22 stores and 472 parking spaces with strong daily traffic of over 18,500 vehicles, providing a convenient shopping destination with a diverse tenant mix serving the local community.

Demographics

Property Report

A ready-to-share PDF covering the market and similar centers nearby, trade area demographics and segments, key tenants and brand mix, recent openings and closings with nearby activity, and leasing contacts. Add a comparison to include a page against a brand or another property.

Sign up to see the property report

News

Tenant Mix by Category

14 brands across 11 categories

Gyms + Fitness Facilities
3 (21.4%)
Spa, Massage, + Esthetics
2 (14.3%)
Hair
1 (7.1%)
Hearing Care
1 (7.1%)
Restaurant - Bakery/Desserts
1 (7.1%)
Restaurant - Coffee/Tea
1 (7.1%)
Restaurant - Juice Bars
1 (7.1%)
Restaurant - QSR/Fast Food
1 (7.1%)
Banks + Financial Services
1 (7.1%)
Tax Services
1 (7.1%)
Grocery
1 (7.1%)

All Tenants

Stop & Shop
Stop & Shop
GroceryN/A
Chase
Chase
Banks + Financial ServicesN/A
Re
Retro Fitness
Gyms + Fitness FacilitiesN/A
••
•••••••••••
•••••••N/A
••
•••••••••••
•••••••N/A
••
•••••••••••
•••••••N/A
••
•••••••••••
•••••••N/A
••
•••••••••••
•••••••N/A

See the full tenant roster and category breakdown

Get started with our Intelligence tier for just $49/month