Big Box/Grocery Center

Nicolls Plaza

Nicolls Plaza is a 381,342 SF Big Box/Grocery Center at 255 Pond Path, South Setauket, NY, USA, with 8 tenants including Target, The Home Depot, and Stop & Shop. In the last 24 months it recorded 1 opening and 1 closing. The 10-minute drive-time population is 47,967 with a median household income of $134,785, according to Brandmarch.

Open-air·8 stores across 381,342 SF·255 Pond Path, South Setauket, NY, USA

Recent Activity in Last 24 months

Dates shown here are when each event was detected. Actual event may have occurred up to 30 days earlier. Next digest sends Sunday.

Opened
EVgo255 Pond Path · Target
Opened 2025
Closed
Best Buy261 Pond Path
Closed ~Sep 2025
Showing 1-2 of 2 activities
Locations · Growth Trajectory

No change since Q4 2024

Steady tenants · 1 opens, 1 closes

About Nicolls Plaza

Nicolls Plaza is a large 381,342-square-foot power center in South Setauket, New York, anchored by major retailers including Target, Home Depot, and Stop & Shop. Developed by Blumenfeld Development Group, the multi-phase complex offers comprehensive retail shopping with grocery, home improvement, and general merchandise options.

Demographics

Property Report

A ready-to-share PDF covering the market and similar centers nearby, trade area demographics and segments, key tenants and brand mix, recent openings and closings with nearby activity, and leasing contacts. Add a comparison to include a page against a brand or another property.

Sign up to see the property report

News

Tenant Mix by Category

8 brands across 8 categories

EV Charging Stations
1 (12.5%)
Grocery
1 (12.5%)
Home Improvement + Building Supplies
1 (12.5%)
Mass Merchant
1 (12.5%)
Restaurant - Casual
1 (12.5%)
Restaurant - Coffee/Tea
1 (12.5%)
Restaurant - QSR/Fast Food
1 (12.5%)
Vitamins, Nutrition, and Supplements
1 (12.5%)

All Tenants

Target
Target
Mass MerchantN/A
The Home Depot
The Home Depot
Home Improvement + Building SuppliesN/A
Stop & Shop
Stop & Shop
GroceryN/A
••
••••••
•••••••••••••N/A
••
••••••
•••••••••••••N/A
••
••••••
•••••••••••••N/A
••
••••••
•••••••••••••N/A
••
••••••
•••••••••••••N/A

See the full tenant roster and category breakdown

Get started with our Intelligence tier for just $49/month