Who Belongs in the Empty Boxes at Casa Bonita's Shopping Center

By Brandmarch3 min read
Who Belongs in the Empty Boxes at Casa Bonita's Shopping Center

A new owner just paid $30.2 million for Lamar Station Plaza near Denver, and roughly a quarter of it is sitting empty.

The setup

Core Acquisitions and Midloch Investment Partners bought Lamar Station Plaza, a 271,632 square foot shopping center on West Colfax Avenue in Lakewood, Colorado, for $30.2 million. The deal was reported by REBusinessOnline on October 30. The center is about 76 percent leased, which puts roughly 65,000 square feet of space dark, including a vacant anchor box that's been listed as large as 42,000 square feet.

The property's best known tenant isn't a national chain. It's Casa Bonita, the pink-towered, 1,000-seat Mexican restaurant and dinner theater that Trey Parker and Matt Stone bought out of bankruptcy in 2021, which now pulls in more than 650,000 visits a year. Ross Dress for Less, Planet Fitness, Dollar Tree, Dutch Bros and a scatter of local shops round out the roster.

The new owners say they plan a facade upgrade, new signage, a new roof, and parking lot and landscaping work, with Cushman & Wakefield taking over leasing. Neither side has named what's going into the empty boxes yet.

How we ran it

Brandmarch is built to answer exactly that: give it a shopping center, and it returns a ranked list of brands that belong there, with the reasoning. Some people call it a void analysis. First, we filter by size, roughly 7,000 to 42,000 square feet, to match the range of open suites. Run it once across all categories, then again limited to restaurant and personal service, since that's what's filling in around Casa Bonita already.

What the engine says

Brandmarch's top-10 for Lamar Station Plaza all categories: Sportsman's Warehouse (67 overall), Rainbow (66), Boot Barn (65), Tractor Supply Co. (65), La Familia Pawn and Jewelry (62), Do It Best (61), Marshalls (61), Big 5 Sporting Goods (60), Red White and Blue Thrift (60), Camping World (60).

Eight of the ten (everyone but Rainbow and Marshalls) show "Category Not Present," meaning nothing in their category is already leased at the center. Four of the ten already have a named in-house Brandmarch contact on file: Boot Barn (Sandra Spragin), Tractor Supply Co. (Scott Hungate), Marshalls (Sean Anderson) and Red White and Blue Thrift (Salvatore Farruggia). Sportsman's Warehouse, Boot Barn and Tractor Supply are the three with a store format that would actually fit the vacant 40,000-to-42,000-SF anchor box; the rest run smaller.

Filtered to restaurant and personal-service categories only, the top 5 are Wienerschnitzel (70 overall), Baskin Robbins (66), Mountain Mike's Pizza (64), Jack in the Box (64) and Del Taco (63). Wienerschnitzel is the only one of the five flagged "Category Not Present," meaning it's the one food concept the engine sees as a genuine gap rather than something the center's food mix already covers in some form. Two have a named in-house Brandmarch contact: Wienerschnitzel (Laurie New) and Del Taco (Esty Chang); Jack in the Box has a broker contact on file (Nicole Curtis); Baskin Robbins and Mountain Mike's Pizza show "Find contacts." All five would fit comfortably in the smaller boxes on site, nowhere near the scale of the vacant anchor.

Worth watching

A 76 percent leased center next to a 650,000-visit-a-year attraction is an odd mix. Casa Bonita draws the crowd. The rest of the center has to earn its own traffic. Whoever Cushman & Wakefield brings in for that 42,000 square foot anchor box will say a lot about whether the new owners are betting on destination retail or just filling space.

0
0